19.07.2023
Dr. Pepe Schladitz
èŠç¯è«ãšæ
æç¯
è¡çºèŠç¯ãšå¶è£èŠç¯ãšãåºå¥ãã Karl Binding以éã®äºå
çèŠç¯è«ã¯ãé倱ç¯ã®æèã«ãã®çè«çãªéç¹ã眮ãããè°è«ãããŠãããããã«å¯ŸããŠã Pepe Schladitzã®å ±åã¯ãæ
ææŠå¿µããã³æ
æã®äœç³»ã¥ãã«å¯ŸããŠèŠç¯è«ãã©ã®ãããªäœç³»çã»çè«çåž°çµããããããã«éç¹ã眮ããã®ã§ãã£ãã Schladitzã¯ããŸããç§èŠãšãªãèŠç¯è«äžã®æ§æ³ã瀺ãããã®æ§æ³ã¯ãé説ã§ãã客芳çåž°å±è«ã®èŠç¯è«äžã®äžéšæ§é ãæ¹å€çã«åæããããšã§åŸããããã®ã§ãããããã«ããã°ãè¡çºèŠç¯ã¯å±éºæ¹èµ·çŠæ¢ãšè§£éãããããã©ã®ãããªè¡çºãèŠæ±ãããããšã«ãªããã®åºæºã«ã€ããŠã¯é説ãšç°ãªãã客芳çé垞人ã§ã¯ãªãââ人çäžæ³è«ããã®åž°çµãšããŠââå
·äœçãªå人ã§ããããšã«ãªãããããã Schladitzã¯ãå人åãããäžæ®µéã®é倱æŠå¿µãå°åºãããããã«å¯ŸããŠæ
æç¯ã®åºç€ã«ã¯ãé倱ç¯ãšã¯è³ªçã«ç°ãªãïŒæ¬¡çè¡çºèŠç¯ããããšãããã®ããšãããããããäºå説ãæ¯ãšããã Schladitzã¯ããã®ããŒãŒã匷調ããã«éããäžèœæªéã®å¯çœ°æ§ã®åé¡ãšæ£åœåäºç±ã«ããããäºå®ã®é¯èª€ãåé¿äžå¯èœãªå Žåãšãããé説ã®è§£æ±ºã«åé¡ã®ããããŒããæŽçšãããç¶ããŠã Schladitzã¯ãèªèº«ã®æ
ææŠå¿µããã®äœç³»çãªåž°çµãçŽ æããã Frischã«ãªãããæ
æã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãçŠæ¢ã®æ¬¡å
ã«ãããæ
床ã§ãããšããããšãããçœå°å眰æ³èŠã®å Žåã§ãã£ãŠãã責任説ãç¶æããããšãããæåŸã« Schladitzã¯ã䟵害ã®æ
æãšå±æ®åã®æ
æãšã¯åäžã§ãããšããããã€ãåæ³315æ¡d第2é
ã第5é
ãèµ·èããç«æ³è
ã®èŠèã¯çããããã®ã§ãããšããã
åèæç®ãšããŠã Schladitz, Normtheoretische Grundlagen der Lehre von der objektiven Zurechnung â Sicheres Fundament oder Achillesferse?, 2021; ders., ZStW 134 (2022), S. 97
14.02.2023
Dr. Svenja Behrendt
äžå¯èœãªæªéã«ã€ããŠã®èå¯ïŒåæ³çè«ã«ãããäžå¯èœãªãã®ã®æŠå¿µã®åæ±ããšæ§æ䞻矩ã»ãã£ã¹ã³ãŒã¹çè«ã«ããæ³ç解ã®ããã³ã·ã£ã«
ãæ¬å ±åã§ã¯ãåæ³çè«ã«ãããäžå¯èœãªãã®ãšããçŸè±¡ã«ã€ããŠããããæŠå¿µäžã©ã®ããã«åãæ±ãããæ±ããããäžå¿ãšãªãã®ã¯ãè¡çºã®äŒå³ãäºå®ãšããŠãæå³ããçµæãæ¹èµ·ããªãããããã¯æ³ççç±ããåæ³äžã®éèŠæ§ãå
šãæ¬ ãè¡çºäŒå³ã§ãããããªå Žåã§ããã«ãããããããåæ³äžã®äžæ³ãžã®éé£ãæ£åœåãããã®ã¯ãã©ã®ãããªç¶æ³ã«ãããŠãããšããåé¡ã§ããã Svenja Behrendtã¯ãç念åãšããŠãäžæ³ã®åºç€ã¥ãã«é¢ããçš®ã
ã®ã¢ãããŒãã察象ãšããå³æ Œãªå®¢èŠ³çã¢ãããŒãïŒæ±ºå®è«çãªäžçåã«åºã¥ã客芳æ§ïŒããããããªå®¢èŠ³çã¢ãããŒãïŒå€æåºæºãšãªãäž»äœãšããŠå®¢èŠ³ç第äžè
ãä»®å®ããè¡çºèŠç¯ã®ã客芳åãïŒããããŠäž»èŠ³çã¢ãããŒããåºå¥ãããããããããªããããã®ã¢ãããŒãã説åŸçã§ãªãã®ãããããŠããªãæ¯é
çãªäž»èŠ³ã»å®¢èŠ³æ··åšã¢ãããŒãã«ã¯ãè°è«ãæ¯ããã ãã®çè«çåºç€ãèªããããªãã®ãã瀺ãã
ã Behrendtã®äžå¿çãªäž»åŒµã¯ãçã®åé¡ã¯ãæ³ã®ç解ãšè¡çºèŠç¯ã®æ§æ³ã®ä»æ¹ã«ãããšãããã®ã§ãããå°éçè°è«ã«ãããŠã¯ãåäžã®èŠç¯æŠå¿µãèªããããšããè·é¢ã眮ãã¹ãã§ãããš Behrendtã¯ãããæ§æ䞻矩ã»ãã£ã¹ã³ãŒã¹çè«ã«åºã¥ãæ³ç解ãåºç€ãšãããšãåæ³äžè°è«ãããŠããããããäºäŸã«ãããŠã¯ãåæ³äžã®è¡çºèŠç¯ã®éåãååšããŠãããããã§å
šé¢ã«åºãŠããã®ã¯ãåæ³äžã®è¡çºèŠç¯ãç Žãããšã«åããããææã®æŽ»åã«å¯ŸããŠãã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³çã«å¯Ÿå¿ããªããã°ãªããªãã®ããããã ãšããã°ãããã¯ç¹å®ã®åœ¢åŒã§ãªãããªããã°ãªããªãã®ããšããåé¡ã§ãããšããããšãæãããšãªããšããã芳å¯ããè
ïŒå€æããè
ãšããŠã®è§£éè
ïŒäŸãã°ãæ€å¯å®ãè£å€å®ïŒã æœè±¡çãªè¡çºèŠç¯ãšã®é¢ä¿ã§ãè¡çºè
ã®èããå
±æããªããšããå Žåã«ã¯ãååãšããŠãã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³çãªå¯Ÿå¿ãè¡ãå¥æ©ãååšããªããããã«å¯ŸããŠã解éè
ãââè¡çºè
ãšåæ§ã«ââç¹å®ã®çµæãæ¹èµ·ããããšïŒäŸãã°ã人ã殺ãããšïŒãå眰ã§çŠæ¢ãããŠãããšããç¹ãèªããŠããããã ãããã®æœè±¡çãªèŠç¯ãã å
·äœçãªè¡çºäŒå³ãçŠæ¢ããŠããªããšèããŠããã«éããªãã®ã§ããã°ãç¶æ³ã¯ç°ãªãããšã«ãªãïŒç¹ã«ãè¿·ä¿¡ç¯ãããã«ãããïŒã
åèæç®ãšããŠã Behrendt, ZfIStw 2023, 20
26.08.2022
Prof. Dr. Juan Pablo Montiel
Verantwortungsstrukturen und anomale KontexteïŒç責æ§é ãšå€åçæèïŒ
Juan Pablo Montiel ãç¹ã«äž»åŒµããããŒãŒã¯ãåæ³ãã°ããŒãã£ã¯ã¯ãæ
ææ¢éç¯ä»¥å€ã®å Žé¢ã«ãããåæ³äžã®ç責æ§ã®èªå®ã«é倧ãªåé¡ãæ±ããŠãããšãããã®ã§ãããããªãã¡ãé説ã¯ãæ
ææ¢éç¯ã®èŠåããã以å€ã®å
šãŠã®æèã«åãããã«é©çšããããšã§å
šãŠã®äºæ¡ã解決ããããšããŠãããšããã®ã§ãããåé¡ãæ確åããããã«ã Montiel ã¯ããç¯çœªïŒVerbrechenïŒããšãç責æ§é ïŒVerantwortungsstrukturïŒããåºå¥ããããšããå§ãããããã§ã¯ãç¯çœªã®æŠå¿µã¯åäžã®ãã®ã§ãããããããç°ãªãæ§é ã«ãããŠäœ¿çšããããšããããšãåºçºç¹ãšãªããç¯çœªæŠå¿µã¯ãæŸæ£äžå¯èœãªïŒã€ã®å±æ§ã®çµåãããªããïŒã€ããèŠç¯éåãã§ãããç¯çœªè¡çºããåœçœ°æ§ããããã¯ãäžæ³ããšçµã³ã€ãããã®ã§ããã®ã«å¯ŸããŠãããïŒã€ã¯ïŒç¯çœªè¡çºãšè²¬ä»»ãžã®ïŒãåž°å±å¯èœæ§ãã§ããã
ãç¯çœªããšãç責æ§é ãã®åºå¥ã«ãããæçµçã« Montiel ã¯ãïŒçš®é¡ã®æ§é ãåºå¥ãããã¡ã€ã³æ§é ãšãµãæ§é ãããã§ãããã¡ã€ã³æ§é ã¯æ
ææ¢éç¯ã«å¯Ÿå¿ããããããã¡ã€ã³ã§ããã®ã¯ãã°ããŒãã«ã¬ãã«ã§æåãªç«æ³æè¡ã«ãåæ ãããŠããæŽå²çãªçç±ã«ãããããªãã¡ã åæ³å
žã¯ãæ
æç¯ã«ã€ããŠãåºæ¬çæ¡ä»¶ãå
足ãããªãã£ãå Žåã«ç責æ§ãè² ãããããã®ç¹å¥ãªèŠåãæããæ³å
žã§ãããšããã®ãããã§ããããããããæªéã®èŠåããã³é倱ã®èŠåã¯ãæ
ææ¢éç¯ã®èŠåã®äŸå€ãšããŠçŸããããããããŸãã«ãã®ããšã瀺ãã®ã¯ãå
šãŠã®æ§æèŠä»¶èŠçŽ ãå
足ãããŠããªãå Žé¢ã§ã¯ãã¡ã€ã³æ§é ã¯ãµãæ§é ã«ãã£ãŠè£å®ãããå¿
èŠããããšããããšã§ãããè¬æŒã«ãã㊠Montiel ã¯ãïŒã€ã®ãµãæ§é ãããªãã¡ãæªéç¯ã®ãµãæ§é ãšæ¬ 猺ã®ããçµæç¯ã®ãµãæ§é ã®ååšãè«èšŒããã
Montiel ã¯ãæªéäºäŸã«ãããŠå眰ãç§ãããšãå¯èœãªã®ã¯ãç¬ç«ã®ç¯çœªè¡çºãåé¡ãšãªã£ãŠããå Žåã§ãããç責æ§ã®æŽŸç圢åŒãåé¡ãšãªã£ãŠããå Žåã§ã¯ãªããšäž»åŒµããããããªãã°è¡çºè
ã¯ãåž°å±ã®èŠä»¶ãå
足ãããŠããããèŠç¯éåãèªããããªãäºäŸã«ãããŠãåŠçœ°ãããããšã«ãªã£ãŠããŸãããã®ãããªæå³ã§ Montiel ã¯ããã®ãããªé£ç¹ãå
æããããã«ãæªéãæ¿èªããç·è«ã®ã«ãŒã«ã¯ãããè¡çºãèŠç¯éåãšãããããã«æããªããã°ãªããªãç¹æ§ã®èšè¿°ãæäŸãããšã®çµè«ãå°ãã
ç責æ§ã®ç¬¬ïŒã®ãµãæ§é ã¯ããæ¬ çŒºã®ããçµæç¯ïŒdefektbehaftetes ErfolgsdeliktïŒããšåŒã°ãããããã¯ãåå ã«ãããŠèªç±ãªè¡çºãåå ã«ãããŠéæ³ãªè¡çºãé倱ç¯çãè¡çºè
ãæ§æèŠä»¶çè¡çºããèªãæããç責æ§æ¬ 猺ç¶æ
ã§è¡ãäºäŸçŸ€ãããããããã®äºäŸçŸ€ã§å
šãŠã®æ§æèŠä»¶èŠçŽ ãåæã«ååšããããã«ã¯ãç責æ§æ¬ 猺ç¶æ
ãåŒãèµ·ãããè¡çºãå«ããå¿
èŠããããããã®éã«ã¯ããã®è¡çºãã察å¿ããæ§æèŠä»¶ã®å®çŸã«ãéæ¥çã«ã€ãªãããããã®ã§ããããšãèæ
®ãããã
æåŸã«ã Montiel ã¯ãµãæ§é ã©ãããçµã¿åãããå¯èœæ§ããã³çµã¿åãããããšã«ãã£ãŠçããåž°çµã®åé¡ãæ±ãããã®ãã¡ãäŒçµ±çãªç¯çœªè«ã®ç解ã«ãšã£ãŠç¹ã«éèŠãšãªãïŒã€ã®åž°çµã匷調ãããããã®ãããªäœç³»ã§ã¯ããããããé倱ç¯ãã®æªéã®æŠå¿µäžã®å¯èœæ§ãè¯å®ãããããšãããã³ãããªã圢åŒã®ãã®ã§ãããèªèãªãé倱ãã«ã¯ãåæ³äžã®ç責æ§ã¯èªããããªãããšãããã§ããã
08.04.2022
Prof. Dr. Wolfgang Spohn
æ¡ä»¶ä»èŠç¯ã«ããæšè«
ãŸããèŠç¯ã®èªãæ¹ã«ã€ããŠã次ã®ãããªåºæ¬çãªéããããããšã瀺ããããåœçºåœé¡ãšããŠã®èŠç¯ãå®èšçèŠç¯ãšæ¡ä»¶ä»ïŒïŒä»®å®çïŒèŠç¯ãèŠç¯ãšèŠç¯ã®å¯©çŽãé»ç€ºã®èŠç¯åŠ¥åœãšæ瀺ã®èŠç¯åŠ¥åœãäžäººç§°èŠç¹ããå€çã«èŠ³å¯ããçµéšçäºå®ãšããŠã®èŠç¯ãèšè¿°çãªãã®ã«éå
ã§ããªãçæ£ã®ãã®ãšããŠã®äžäººç§°èŠç¹ã«ãããèŠç¯ãªã©ãããã§ããã以äžã§ã¯ãæåŸã®ç解ã®ã¿ãåãäžããããšãšãªãã
第ïŒã«ãæ³è«çããã®æ¹å€ãããªãã¡æ³çäžæ®µè«æ³ãå
žåãšããæ³çæšè«ããå€å
žè«çãçšããŠåœ¢åŒåããããšããè©Šã¿ãåãäžãããäŸãçšããŠãæ³çæšè«ã¯åççã«éå調æšè«ãªããã¯ãè«é§ãæšè«ã§ãããå€å
žè«çã§ã¯æ±ãããšã®ã§ããªãéå調æ¡ä»¶æ³ã«åºã¥ããŠããããšã瀺ãããã
第ïŒã«ãå®èšçèŠç¯ã®è«çã«é¢ããåºæ¬çãªåæã«ã€ããŠç°¡åãªçŽ¹ä»ããã£ããããã¯ãå²åŠçè«çããªãã¡çŸ©åè«çã®äžéšã§ããããã®æšæºçäœç³»ãæ§ç¯ãããŠãããã®ã§ããããšã信念è«çïŒåçç信念ã®è«çïŒãšåãæ§é ãæã€ããšãããã§ããããããã®è«çã¯ãã¹ãŠãç°è«ã®äœå°ã®ãªããã®ã§ã¯ãªãããšã¯åœç¶ã§ããã
第ïŒã«ãæ¡ä»¶ä»èŠç¯ã®è«çãžã®æ¡åŒµã®åé¡ãæ±ã£ãããã®ãããªæ¡åŒµãè¡ãã«ã¯ã1968幎以éã«çºå±ããæ¡ä»¶è«çã®åé¡ã«ç«ã¡å
¥ãå¿
èŠãããããšããã®ã¯æ¡ä»¶è«çã«ãããŠã¯æ³çæšè«ã®åœ¢åŒåã®ããã«å¿
èŠãšãªãéå調æ¡ä»¶æ³ãåé¡ãšãªãããã§ããããã®åé¡ã§ã¯ã¢ãããŒãã®å€æ§åãé²ãã§ããããããéèŠã§ãããã〠Spohn ãæ¯æããã¢ãããŒãã¯ããããã Ramsey ãã¹ããšæ¡ä»¶æ³ã®ä¿¡å¿µè«çã«åºã¥ã解éãšã«åºã¥ããã®ã§ããã
第ïŒã«ããã®ãããªã¢ãããŒããæ¡ä»¶ä»èŠç¯ã®ç解ãšãã®è«ççææ¡ã«é©ãããã®ã§ããããšãè¿°ã¹ããããå ããŠããã®ãããªã¢ãããŒããçå£ã«ãšãããæã«æ³çè«ã®èªå·±ç解ã«èµ·ããåçãªåž°çµã«ã€ããŠã説æããã£ããããããããã¯çå£ã«ãšãããå Žåã®è©±ã§ãããå€å
žè«çã«åºã¥ãåŸæ¥ã®èªå·±ç解ã¯ãçµå±ã®ãšããäžååã§ãã£ãããšã瀺ãããã
第ïŒã«ã Chisholm ã®ãã©ããã¯ã¹ãšåŒã°ãããã®ãåé¡ãšãªã£ãã矩åè«çã§ã¯ããã®ãã©ããã¯ã¹ãã©ã®ããã«ããã°é©åã«æ±ãããããªãäžæ確ã§ããã Spohn ã¯ããã®ãã©ããã¯ã¹ããããããèŠç¯çèšèª¬ã«éåºããïŒãããŠã Spohn ã«ããã°ãã©ããã¯ã¹ã®åºç€ã«ããïŒæ ¹æ¬çãªææ§ãã説æããããã«å°å
¥ãããããªãã¡ãïŒå
ç䟡å€ãšå€ç䟡å€ã®åºå¥ããåããèªäœããšãæ段ãšããŠã®åãã®åºå¥ã«é¡äŒŒããïŒçŽç²ãªèŠç¯ãšäºå®ã«å°ãããèŠç¯ã®ææ§ããããã§ãããæ¡ä»¶ä»è«çã«é¢ãã Spohn ã®èª¬æãåæ§ã«äžæ確ã§ãã£ããããããæ£ç¢ºã«èªã¿è§£ãã°ããã®èª¬æã¯çŽç²ãªèŠç¯ã«ã®ã¿é¢ãããã®ã§ãã£ãã
第ïŒã«ãïŒæ³ã®æèã§ã¯ã»ãŒåžžã«åé¡ãšãªããå°ãªããšãæ³çäžæ®µè«æ³ã«ãããŠã¯åé¡ãšãªãïŒäºå®ã«å°ãããèŠç¯ã®è«çã«éããããã«ã¯äœãããã«å¿
èŠãã«ã€ããŠãå±æã瀺ãããããã®ããã«ã¯ã Spohn ã40幎ããããŠçºå±ããããŸãåºããŠããããããã©ã³ã¯çè«ã«èžã¿èŸŒãããšãäžå¯æ¬ ãšãªããæ¬è¬æŒã¯ä»¥äžã®ãtake-home messagesãã§éããããã
1. å€å
žè«çã¯ãæ³çè«çã«ã¯é©ããŠããªãã
2. éå調æ¡ä»¶æ³ãç 究ããã
3. çŽç²ãªèŠç¯ãšãäºå®ã«å°ãããèŠç¯ãšãå³æ Œã«åºå¥ããã
åèæç®ãšããŠã Spohn, RPhZ 2022, S. 5â38

20.01.2022
Prof. Dr. Juan Pablo Mañalich
æ§æçèŠåäœç³»ãšããŠã®ç¹æ§ãæã€åæ³äžã®å¶è£èŠç¯äœç³»ã®ééæ§
æ¬å ±åã¯ãåæ³ã«ãããæ³åŸäž»çŸ©ã®ãééèŠåïŒSchlieÃungsregel/residual closure ruleïŒããšããŠã®æ§è³ªãæ±ããç¹ã«åé¡ãšããã®ã¯ãæ³åŸäž»çŸ©ã«ã€ããŠäžè¬çã«èšãããç¹æ§ãããªãã¡ãåæ³äžçŠæ¢ããããŠããªãè¡çºã¯ãã¹ãŠããåæ³äžèš±å®¹ãããŠãããã®ãšã¿ãªããããšãšãªãèŠåãšããŠã®ç¹æ§ã§ããããšããã®ããåæ³äžã®å¶è£èŠç¯ã¯ââ Wesley Hohfeld ã®çšèªæ³ã«èšãââèŠå¶çèŠåïŒ regulative RegelnïŒã«åé¡ãããã®ãéåžžã§ãããããããæ§æçèŠåïŒ konstitutive RegelnïŒãšããŠãããªãã¡åœå®¶æš©åã«åããããåŠçœ°çŸ©åãç«ã¡äžãããããã®ãšããŠãç解ãããã¹ãã ããã§ããïŒãã®ããã«ç解ãããšã Binding ãããã®äž»èãèŠç¯ãšãã®éåãã®ç¬¬2çã§ãã§ã«ãå眰æ³èŠãã矩åãåºç€ä»ããã«é©ããèŠç¯ãšãšãããç解ããè·é¢ã眮ããçç±ãæãããšãªãïŒã
åæ³äžã®å¶è£èŠç¯ãæ§æçèŠåã«ã«ããŽã©ã€ãºããçºæ³ã¯ã Hart ã®èŠç¯è«ã«ãèŠããããããã§ã¯ãæ³åŸäžã®å¶è£ã¯ããããã2次çåž°å±èŠåïŒsecondary rules of adjudicationãæ¥æ¬èªã§ã¯ãéäŸã第2次ã«ãŒã«ãšããŠã®è£å®ã®ã«ãŒã«ãšèš³ããããïŒã®äžäœã®åœ¢æ
ãšãããã2次çåž°å±èŠåãšã¯ã察å¿ããæ³äœç³»ã圢äœãèŠåã®å¶åºŠçãªé©çšãå·è¡ã®æ¡ä»¶ã圢åŒãå¹æãå
·äœåããæ§æçèŠåã§ãããšäžè¬ã«ç解ãããŠãããã®ã§ããããã®ãããªç解ã®ããšã§ã¯ãïŒåæ³äžã®ïŒå¶è£èŠç¯ã¯ãå¶è£è³Šèª²ãäºå®ãããŠãã矩åã«éåããå Žåã«ãããªãå眰ãç§ãããå
·äœåãããŸãã¯å°ãªããšãéçä»ããèŠåã§ããããšã«ãªããåæ³äžã®å¶è£èŠç¯ãé©çšå¯èœãšãªãã®ã¯ãããè
ã®ïŒåž°å±å¯èœãªïŒæ
床ããã®èŠç¯ã®åææ¡ä»¶ãå
足ããŠããããã®è
ãç¹å®ã®ã Hohfeld ã®èšãæææ§ïŒVerbindlichkeit/liabilityïŒã«å¯Ÿå¿ããå¶åºŠçå°äœãå ããããã«å¯Ÿå¿ããå°äœã Hohfeld ã®èšãå®åïŒMacht/powerïŒã§ããå Žåã§ãããããã«ããã°ãåæ³äžã®å¶è£èŠç¯ã¯æ§æçèŠåã§ããããããèŠä»¶ã®å
足ãšåæ³äžã®å¶è£ãçµã³ã€ããããšã«ããããå眰ã®ç䟡æ§ïŒStrafÀquivalenzïŒãïŒBindingïŒãçã¿åºãããã®ã§ããã
ããã§ãããããåæ³äžã®æ³åŸäž»çŸ©ãã©ã®çšåºŠãŸã§ééèŠåã§ããããšããåœåã®åé¡ã«ç«ã¡è¿ãããšãã§ãããééèŠåã«ããéããããããããªäœç³»ã圢äœãèŠåãäžæ¹ã«ãããééèŠåããèªäœãä»æ¹ã«ãããäž¡è
ã¯ç¯çè«çã«å質ã§ãªããã°ãªããªããããªãã¡ãç¹å®ã®èŠåäœç³»ãéããããšã®ã§ãããããªèŠåã¯ããã®äœç³»ã®èŠåãšåãçš®é¡ã®èŠåã«å±ããŠããªããã°ãªããªãã Hohfeld ã®èšãã匷ããå°äœãšã匱ããå°äœãšãââããªãã¡ãåé¡ãšãªãèŠç¯äœç³»ã«å±ããèŠåããçããå°äœãšãå察ã®å
容ãæããèŠåãæããªãäœç³»ããçããå°äœãšãââããã«åºå¥ãããšã以äžã®åž°çµãå°ããããããªãã¡ãåæ³äžã®æ³åŸäž»çŸ©ã¯ãæ§æçãªééèŠåãšç解ãããã¹ãã§ãããããã«ããã°ãæ³åŸäžã®å¶è£èŠç¯ã«ãã£ãŠåŠçœ°ãããªãè
ã¯ãåŠçœ°ãããŠã¯ãªããªããšããããšãããã§ããã
18.10.2021
PD Dr. Stephan Ast
æ°ã«ã³ã䞻矩ã®æ§æèŠä»¶çè«
æ¬è¬æŒã¯çè«å²çç 究ã§ããããã®ããŒã¹ã«ããã®ã¯ãä»æ¥ãªãæ矩ãæããåé¡ãããªãã¡ãè¡çºãæçºãæ§æèŠä»¶ãã©ã®ãããªãã®ãšæ§æ³ãããã§ããããŸãåºçºç¹ãšããŠãæ°ã«ã³ã掟ã®åœ±é¿ãåããåæ³åŠè
ã®æ§æèŠä»¶çè«ã¯ã«ã³ãçã§ããã®ããåãããããçµè«ãšããŠãããã«ã¯åŠå®çãªåçãäžããããã
ããæ§æèŠä»¶çè«ãåºç€ã¥ããããšããã°ãããã«ã¯ããã«å¯Ÿå¿ããè¡çºæŠå¿µããããæ°ã«ã³ã䞻矩ã®åæ³åŠè
ã¯ã von Lisztãš Belingãåºç€ã¥ããè¡çºç解ã決å®çã«åŒãç¶ãã§ãããæ§æèŠä»¶çè¡çºïŒããªãã¡æçºïŒã¯ãåæ³ã«ããçŠæ¢ã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãšããŠãããããéæ³æ§å€æã責任å€æã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãšããããè¡çºãšæ§æèŠä»¶å®çŸã®é¢ä¿ã¯ãå€ãã®å Žåã次ã®ããã«ç解ããããããªãã¡ãè¡çºãšã¯èº«äœéåã§ãã£ãŠãæçºããããæå³ã«é¢ããããããèŠçŽ ãå
æãããã®ãšããŠã®æçºã®åãªãç©ççæ
ãæã«éããããããããè¡çºãæ§æèŠä»¶æ§ãåãããã¯ãå¶ç¶çãªãã®ã§ãããšããã®ãããã§ããã
ããã«å¯ŸããŠã Kantã身ã眮ãçæ§æ³ã®äŒçµ±ã§ã¯ãè¡çºãšã¯ãåž°å±å€æã®åž°çµãšããŠæ§æ³ããããåž°å±å€æã¯ãããå€åãèµ·ãã£ãããšããããã¯ãããèµ·ãããªãã£ãããšããããäººæ Œã«åž°ãããããã®ã§ãããåž°å±ã®å¯Ÿè±¡ã«é¢ããæ
æãŸãã¯é倱ããåž°å±æ ¹æ ãšããŠæ¿èªãããŠãããããããè¡çºãšã¯ãå æçç解ãšã¯ç°ãªããç¹å®ã®æ§è³ªãæã€ç©ãŸãã¯åºæ¥äºãšããŠææ¡ãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãããã®ç®çããããã¯ããæ£ç¢ºã«ã¯ãã®æ©èœã«ãã£ãŠå€æãããé¢ä¿ç圢象ãšããŠç解ãããããã®åž°çµãšããŠãæ©èœã®å
足ã«é¢ããèŠçŽ ââäŸãã°æ
æãŸãã¯é倱ââã¯å¯å€çãªãã®ãšãªãã
ãããã®è¡çºç解çžäºã®å¯Ÿç«ã¯ã von Lisztãè¡çºã«åž°å±æ©èœãèªããŠããªãã£ãããšãèæ
®ããã°ãçžå¯Ÿçãªãã®ãšããããåž°å±ã¯ãæ
æãŸãã¯é倱ãšç解ãããæå³ã§ã®è²¬ä»»ã«ã€ããŠã®å€æã«ãã£ãŠã¯ãããŠè¡ãããã®ã§ãããç¹ã« Radbruchã¯ãè¡çºæŠå¿µããåæ³äžã®äžæ³å€æã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãå®ããããã®ãåãªãæ³åŸäžã®æè¡çæŠå¿µãšããŠæ§æ³ãããããããå æçç解ã§ã¯ã RadbruchããŸãã«äž»åŒµãã課é¡ãæããããªãã£ããããã«ä»£ããŠåœŒã¯ãæçºïŒæ§æèŠä»¶å®çŸïŒãäœç³»ã®åºæ¬æŠå¿µã«æ®ããã®ã§ããã
ãããã«å¯ŸããŠã Honigã¯ãæ§æèŠä»¶ããè¡çºã®æ§é ã®åé¡ãšé¢é£ã¥ããã圌ã¯ãçæ§æ³ã®äŒçµ±ããã©ããç¯çœªè¡çºãããã®åž°å±æ©èœã«ãã£ãŠå®çŸ©ãããåž°å±æ ¹æ ãšããŠãæ§æèŠä»¶çè¡çºçµæã®ç®çå¯èœæ§ãæ®ããã®ã§ããããã®ããã«ããŠãè¡çºãšæ§æèŠä»¶ã®åé¢ãšããåãå
¥ããããæ§æãä¹ãè¶ãããšãšãã«ã身äœéåãçµæããããŠè¡çºã®æå³çåŽé¢ãé£åãããããšã®ã§ããªãè¡çºã®å æçç解ãä¹ãè¶ããã®ã§ããã
ã Welzelããè¡çºã®å æçç解ã«åºå·ãã€ã€ãããããæå³çµ±äžäœãšããŠææ¡ãããããããå
容çã«èŠãã°ãçæ§æ³ã®äŒçµ±ãšåãããã«ãæ
æãŸãã¯é倱ãåž°å±æ ¹æ ãšããŠç解ããŠããââãã¡ããããããã責任ããåãé¢ããŠç解ããŠãããšããç¹ã§ä¿®æ£ãããŠããã®ã ããããããŠãæ°ã«ã³ã掟ã«ç¶ãäžä»£ã«ãªã£ãŠã Kantã®å®è·µå²åŠãžã®åæ¥åãè¡ãããã®ã§ããã
åèæç®: Ast, Vom Zurechnungs- zum Kausalkonzept â Handlung und Tat von der Philosophie der AufklÀrung bis zur Strafrechtswissenschaft der Weimarer Zeit, in: Pawlik/Stuckenberg/Wohlers (Hrsg.), Strafrecht und Neukantianismus, 2023, S. 311â324
28.07.2021
Dr. Zhiwei Tang
äžåœïŒåïŒæ³åŠã«ãããèŠç¯è«ããããè°è«
æ¬å ±åã¯ãäžåœïŒåïŒæ³åŠã«ãããèŠç¯è«ããããè°è«ã®ç¶åç¶æ³ãšçŸåšã«ãããè°è«ã®éç¹ãæããã«ãããã®ã§ããããšããã以äžã®3ç¹ãåé¡ãšãããããªãã¡ãïŒ1ïŒäžåœã«ãããŠèŠç¯ããããã¯èŠç¯è«ãã©ã®ããã«ç解ãããŠããããïŒ2ïŒäžåœã«ãããèŠç¯è«ã«é¢ããè°è«ã®çŸç¶ãšèæ¯ã¯ã©ã®ãããªãã®ããïŒ3ïŒäžåœïŒåïŒæ³åŠã®çºå±ã«ãšã£ãŠèŠç¯è«ã¯ãã©ã®ãããªå¯äžããã©ã®ç¹ã§ãªãããã®ãããããã§ããã
I. äžåœã«ãããèŠç¯æŠå¿µããã³èŠç¯ã®äžè¬çè«ã«é¢ããè°è«
äžåœã«ãããŠæåãªã®ã¯ããªã«ããããœãŽã£ãšãã»ãã·ã¢çãªåœå®¶ææ³ãæ³ææ³ã«ç±æ¥ããå¶è£è«çãªèŠç¯ç解ã§ãããããã«åºã¥ããŠãåæ³ã®é åã«ãããŠããå眰æ³èŠã«ã¯äºéã®æ§è³ªããããšããçè«ãå€æ°èª¬ãšããŠäž»åŒµãããŠãããããã«ãããšå眰æ³èŠã¯ãäžæ¹ã§ã¯è£å€å®ã«åããããè£å€èŠç¯ã§ãããä»æ¹ã§ã¯å
¬è¡ã«åããããè¡çºèŠç¯ã§ãããBinding以æ¥ã®ãã€ãã®äŒçµ±çæå³ã«ãããè¡çºèŠç¯ãšå¶è£èŠç¯ã®åºå¥ãšã¯ç°ãªããå眰æ³èŠã®äºéæ§è³ªèª¬ã«ããè¡çºèŠç¯ãšè£å€èŠç¯ãšã¯ãè¡šè£äžäœã®é¢ä¿ã«ããããã®ãããªåæ³èŠç¯ã®ç解ã¯ãè¡çºèŠç¯ãšå¶è£èŠç¯ãšã®æ§é ã®éããã2ã€ã®èŠç¯ã¯é£åãã€ã€ããåºå¥ããŠèå¯ããªããã°ãªããªãããšãèŠèœãšããŠããåèŠä»¶ç¯çœªè«ã«ãé倧è©äŸ¡ã¯ã§ããªããäžå®ã®åœ±é¿ãåãŒããã
II. å€åœæ³ããã®èŠç¯è«ã®æ°ããªç¶å
è¿æãæ¥æ¬æ³ããã³ãã€ãæ³ããã®æ°ããªç¥èŠãç¶åãããŠã以äžã®ãããªäŒçµ±çãªèŠç¯ç解ãšå¯Ÿç«ããŠããããã®ãããªç¶åã®æµãã¯ã以åã¯èŠãããªãã£ãããšã§ãããããã®çç±ã¯ãåŸæ¥ã¯ãèŠç¯è«ãæ³åŸåŠã®åŠè¡äº€æµã«ãããŠã¯è圹ãšããŠã®æ±ãã«ãããéå®çãåã
çãªçŽ¹ä»ããã«ãå€ãã®èª€è§£ãçããŠããããã§ããã
III. å°æ¥ã®å±æïŒäžåœã«ãããèŠç¯è«ã®å±é
èŠç¯è«ããäžåœã«ãããåæ³çè«äžã®è°è«ãè±ãã«ã§ãããã®ã§ããããšã«ã¯äœã®çä¿ããªããäžæ³è«ããããè°è«ãšäžŠã³ãèŠç¯è«ã¯ãæ§ã
ãªçè«çäºç¹ââââäŸãã°ãäžåœåæ³ã®æ§æèŠä»¶ã«ããèŠãããéçèŠçŽ ã®åœ¹å²ââââã®è§£æ±ºã®ãµããŒããšãªããããã®ã§ããããã®ããã«ã¯ããŸãã¯èŠç¯è«ââââæ£ç¢ºã«ã¯ãèŠç¯ã«é¢ããè«žçè«ââââã®çºå±ã®æµããæããã«ããããããã®çè«ã®ç«ã¡äœçœ®ãã©ã®ããã«ç°ãªã£ãŠããããæµ®ã圫ãããããšãæçã§ããããã®æå³ã§ãæ¬ã¯ãŒãã³ã°ã°ã«ãŒããããããšããŠããããšã¯ãäžåœåæ³åŠã®ãããªãçºå±ã«ãšã£ãŠã®éèŠãªåºç€ãšãªããã®ã§ããã
01.12.2020
PD Dr. David Kuch
æ³äœç³»ââèŠç¯åé¡ââè¡çºçç±
æ¬å ±åã¯ãJoseph RazïŒ*1939幎ïŒã®æ³ææ³ã«ãããèŠç¯è«çåŽé¢ãæããã«ãããã®ã§ããã泚ç®ããã®ã¯ã1970幎ãã1985幎é ã«ãããŠå
¬è¡šãããåæã®æ¥çžŸã§ããããã®ææã®æ¥çžŸã¯ãå¶åºŠçæ³çè«ïŒI.ïŒãå
æ¬çãªå®è·µå²åŠäžã®æèã«çµã¿èŸŒãããšãããã®ã§ããïŒII.ïŒãRazã®æèéçšã®ãããã®ç¹ã«ãããŠããç矩ã®èŠç¯è«çåé¡ãšã®æ¥ç¹ãèŠãããã
I. æ³çè«äžã®åæ¯ïŒå¶åºŠè«çå®èšŒäž»çŸ©
Razã®åæã®æ¥çžŸã¯ãH.L.A. Hartã®å€å
žçå
è¡ç 究ã§ãããæ³ã®æŠå¿µãThe Con-cept of LawããïŒ1961幎ïŒãã匷ã圱é¿ãåããŠãããæ³ã®ãäºéã®å¶åºŠåãïŒPaul BohannanïŒãç¶æ¿ããŠãããèŠç¯è«ã«ãããŠãããšå¯Ÿå¿ããã®ããäžæ¬¡èŠåãšäºæ¬¡èŠåã®åºå¥ã§ãããèŠç¯åé¡ã®ã«ããŽãªãŒãšããŠãã®åºåãããã«æšªæãããã®ãããã€ããããç¹ã«çŸ©å賊課èŠåãšæš©èœä»äžèŠåã®åºå¥ããããã¯å®ç«ãããèŠç¯ãšå®åèŠåã®åºå¥ãéèŠã§ããã
II. ïŒæ³ïŒå²åŠäžã®èæ¯ïŒè¡çºçç±ã®çè«
ãå®è·µççç±ãšèŠç¯ãPractical Reason and NormsããïŒ1975幎ïŒã¯ãæ³çè«ã«ãããRazã®äž»èã§ãããåæžã¯ãæ³ã«ãµããããèŠç¯æ§ã®çè«ãå®ç«ããããšãããã®ã§ããããã®äžå¿ãšãªãã®ãè¡çºçç±ã®æŠå¿µã§ããããã®äžã§èŠç¯è«ã«ãšã£ãŠæãéèŠãªã€ãããŒã·ã§ã³ãããæä»ççç±ãexclusionary reasonsãããšããŠã®èŠç¯è§£éã§ãããããã«Razã¯ãHans Kelsenã«äŸæ ããèŠç¯èšè¿°åœé¡ã®çè«ïŒè·é¢ã眮ããèšæãdetached statementsãïŒãçŽ æããŠããããããã®ããŒãã«ã€ããŠããç®äžãã€ãã§ã¯ååã«ç¶åãããŠãããšã¯ãããªãïŒãã®ç¹ã«ã€ããvgl. Kuch, Die AutoritÀt des Rechts, 2016ïŒã
III. ãªã¢ãªãºã ãšæç䞻矩ã®ã¯ããŸã§
Razã®ã¢ãããŒãå
šäœã¯ããªã¢ãªãºã ãšæç䞻矩ãšã®ç¬ç¹ãªäžŠç«ãšããç¹åŸŽãæããŠããããã«æããããããã«ã¯ãåææ³åŠã«ãšã£ãŠæ¥µããŠéèŠãªèåŸè
ã«ïŒMax WeberãšäžŠãã§ïŒæ°ããããLudwig WittgensteinãšãJoseph Razãšã®ç¥çãªå質æ§ãããããã¯æµ®ãã³äžãã£ãŠããã®ã§ããã